Some Kickball Etiquette From the SEC; Commission Management Goes on Trial
Commissions win this week ...

Here at Incisive Media in New York, we have a company kickball team that played valiantly in defeat last night.
Now, mind you, our opponent had won their previous game 24-0 ... which, in a game that lasts only six innings or an hour (whichever comes first), is pretty impressive ─ nearly impossible really. So we expected an uphill battle.
What we didn't expect is that they would actively bend (and in many cases break) as many rules as possible — where, as anyone who has played in a club sport will know, the umpires at these things usually aren't all that observant.
As my colleague Anthony Malakian often says when the subject of steroids in sport comes up, "if you ain't cheatin', you ain't tryin.'" But it's a bit worse when you turn the "cheatin'" into the game itself, knowing full well that you'll get away with it.
I get the feeling that some (certainly not all) dark pool operators have treated their business this way a little bit over the years, too. Running dark liquidity, you get a bit used to having a lot of proprietary information flowing in about both the markets in general and certain participants — anonymous on-screen or not — in particular.
It's a constant battle trying to create new ways to attract those participants, or keep them happy, and that means a lot of test projects and algos running at once. For agency-only brokers especially, there are a lot of fine lines to straddle and walls to mind, and falling afoul of any can get you into a sticky situation.
Likewise, it's a constant battle trying to create new ways to attract those participants, or keep them happy, and that means a lot of test projects and algos running at once. For agency-only brokers especially, there are a lot of fine lines to straddle and walls to mind, and falling afoul of any can get you into a sticky situation very quickly.
Again, in most cases, they're able to get away with it, catching themselves and making the needed technical fixes before anyone gets wise.
This week, though, ITG had to pay the piper after the mainstay broker settled the largest penalty ever for an ATS with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) — shortly after a new chief executive was installed.
In relative terms, a roughly $20 million penalty is tiny compared to the massive fines recently levied on banks in the hundreds of millions; the dollars aren't meant to create a real bite here, especially given the voluntary turnover in the C-suite.
But it's a marker nonetheless, and portends more trouble for the bank-owned dark pools already under review by enforcement authorities for potential breaches of client confidence.
The umpires, it seems, have had enough.
A Different Storm Gathering
Not every commission is of the regulatory variety, though. Investment research commission dollars have long represented a reliable, low-margin boon for the sell side over the years.
Some say it's been too reliable and easy, though. Clouds are starting to gather in Europe, where ESMA has made a surprisingly large deal out of commission unbundling as part of the run-up to MiFID II in 2017 — most notably requiring investment managers to keep closer track of their broker voting and budgeting processes, and worse, by requiring them to develop alternative ways to pay for research ... either through charging investors or running it through their own internal P&L. Quite the squeeze.
This could kill research as we know it, argued one source — calling it a hugely unnecessary but predictable consequence of overreach — or, in the very least, it could nudge some asset managers' operations offshore in a clear-as-day case of regulatory arbitrage.
Whether that happens or not, or how, still remains to be seen. But what is crystal clear is that the tech community needs to step up and help the buy side cope. A number of providers — both new and established, big and small — are already jumping into the mix; some building out full commission management workflows while others focus on custom modules. Clearly, change is afoot.
I'll be examining the issue in-depth for the September issue of Waters, and anyone with thoughts on all of this should feel free to reach out on 646 490 3968 or shoot me an email.
Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.
To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@waterstechnology.com or view our subscription options here: http://subscriptions.waterstechnology.com/subscribe
You are currently unable to print this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.
You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
As outlined in our terms and conditions, https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/ (point 2.4), printing is limited to a single copy.
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@waterstechnology.com
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
You may share this content using our article tools. As outlined in our terms and conditions, https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/ (clause 2.4), an Authorised User may only make one copy of the materials for their own personal use. You must also comply with the restrictions in clause 2.5.
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@waterstechnology.com
More on Emerging Technologies
M&A activity, syndicated loans, a new tariff tool, and more
The Waters Cooler: LSEG and LeveL Markets partner for new order type, QuantHouse gets sold to Baha Tech, and Fitch Ratings has a new interactive tool in this week’s news roundup.
Nasdaq, AWS offer cloud exchange in a box for regional venues
The companies will leverage the experience gained from their relationship to provide an expanded range of services, including cloud and AI capabilities, to other market operators.
OCC’s security chief on generative AI with guardrails
Clearinghouse looks to scale technology across risk and data operations—but safety is still the watchword.
Bank of America reduces, reuses, and recycles tech for markets division
Voice of the CTO: When it comes to the old build, buy, or borrow debate, Ashok Krishnan and his team are increasingly leaning into repurposing tech that is tried and true.
Waters Wavelength Ep. 313: FIS Global’s Jon Hodges
This week, Jon Hodges, head of trading and asset services for Apac at FIS Global, joins the podcast to talk about how firms in Asia-Pacific approach AI and data.
Project Condor: Inside the data exercise expanding Man Group’s universe
Voice of the CTO: The investment management firm is strategically restructuring its data and trading architecture.
BNP Paribas explores GenAI for securities services business
The bank recently released a new web app for its client portal to modernize its tech stack.
Bank of America and AI, exchanges feud with researchers, a potential EU tax on US tech, and more
The Waters Cooler: Broadridge settles repos in real time, Market Structure Partners strikes back at European exchanges, and a scandal unfolds in Boston in this week’s news roundup.