Opening Cross: Buy, Build or Bust?

In light of two recent developments in the market data world, Max looks at the pros and cons of each side of the buy versus build debate.

max-bowie

If you choose to buy technology rather than build it in-house, the good news is that your project will generally come in cheaper than building it from scratch yourself, because you can leverage vendors’ “build-once-sell-many-times” economies of scale—and that includes not only the “raw materials” cost of hardware and software licenses, but also the cost of hiring staff—or the opportunity cost of taking them away from other projects—with the requisite skills. There’s also the fact that—especially in today’s fast-moving markets, where being first to market can deliver a fleeting yet worthwhile advantage—it’s quicker to deploy an off-the-shelf solution than building one yourself.

For example, if I need a new kettle, I’m going to walk the store and buy one. Even if I were an electrical engineer, I doubt I’d (a) be able to do that on the fly; (b) be able to buy the components cheaper than the cost of a new kettle; and (c) get it done in time to fulfill the client requirement—i.e., make myself a cup of coffee.

But on the other hand, if you buy the same tools as everyone else, you should expect to perform only as well—or as badly—as everyone else. And one of the reasons that firms pursue in-house builds is because they think they can deliver an advantage over the commodity tools available on the market. Indeed, that’s how a lot of low-latency developments eventually became mainstream—because initially firms built their own feed handlers or microwave networks. Once everyone else has caught up, they can buy off-the-shelf again, but in the meantime, they’ve had an advantage, and an opportunity to make more money.

Another reason firms are willing to build in-house—even when it might be clearly more expensive to do so—is to avoid vendor lock-in that could prove much more expensive in the long term. A kettle might be cheap, but when I also have to buy that manufacturer’s proprietary power adapter plus a special water filter to prevent limescale buildup, and an extension cord because this wonderful new kettle won’t fit where my old one did, the incremental costs add up—and that sunk investment makes me more likely to buy the same kettle again, rather than switching brands if I know I’m going to have to replace all those incidentals.

For example, low-cost data terminal provider Money.Net has begun building its own “next-generation” news service, leveraging a combination of traditional journalism and artificial intelligence to identify and break market-moving corporate news faster than traditional wires. The vendor chose to build the service itself—as it does with other aspects of its platform—because it feels this gives it more control over creativity, quality, build speed and costs, says chief executive Morgan Downey.

On the other hand, data inventory monitoring and cost control software vendor The Roberts Group has acquired Priory Solutions, a provider of similar services for the legal industry, in no small part because of Priory’s ability to provide detailed usage tracking around content delivered over the internet. This isn’t to say that TRG couldn’t build that functionality itself, given time, but the acquisition allows the vendor to start using it right away, and benefitting from an advantage that its competitors may not have.

Is there a third way that can not only make finding the right tools less of a stark choice, and gives you an element of both buy and build while mitigating the risks of each? Well, yes—at least, sort of—but I’ll save that discussion for another time. 

Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.

To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@waterstechnology.com or view our subscription options here: http://subscriptions.waterstechnology.com/subscribe

You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.

You need to sign in to use this feature. If you don’t have a WatersTechnology account, please register for a trial.

Sign in
You are currently on corporate access.

To use this feature you will need an individual account. If you have one already please sign in.

Sign in.

Alternatively you can request an individual account here